Bison Pump Vs Simple Pump [Which is Best?]

So, you’re thinking about building a well for your home and you’re not sure which pump is the best for you. Two popular pumps are the bison and simple pump.

That’s why in this article, we’ll compare the Bison pump vs Simple pump. This is the only article you’ll need to read comparing Bison and Simple pumps.

Let’s dig in.

There are several factors to consider when considering Bison Pump vs Simple Pump.

Some of these factors include how fast and easy is it to install, how deep can the pump go, how high quality is the pump, and what’s the deal with the pricing and warranty.

By the way, here’s our article on how to dig a well yourself.

Let’s start off with how easy these pumps are to install. 


Generally speaking, simple pumps are built to last 3-10 years. On the other hand, Bison pumps are meant to last a lifetime. 

This is given you’re doing regular maintenance for your pumps. So, Bison Pumps win this one!


The instructions are somewhat similar, but the Simple Pump is easier to install, as there are fewer steps involved and lighter materials to move around.

You can install the Simple pump in around an hour, if you’re generally good with these kinds of things. Although, if you have trouble understanding instructions then it may take several hours.

The Bison Pump on the other hand may require professionals. But, if you’re skilled at these sorts of things, it may only take a few hours for you to install.

In terms of ease of installation, the Simple Pump wins. 

Simple Pump Installation

Bison Pump Installation


Well pump depth matters because the deeper the well is, the more water pressure is needed to bring the water to the surface. 

Bison Pumps can easily lift the water up from 300 feet down in the ground. You will need to be strong though since the deeper you go down, the hard it is to pump.

On the other hand, Simple Pumps can go 325 feet down. Thus, the Simple Pump wins depth by a hair.


Now we’re talking about the actual quality of the well pumps.

First off, the simple pump is made of stainless steel and aluminum (the aluminum doesn’t touch the water). It’s generally lower quality than the Bison Pump.

Bison Pumps are 100% stainless steel and are made in a way it’s heavy-duty and lasts a lifetime. Therefore, Bison Pumps wins quality by a large margin.

Price & Warranty

Finally, we have price and warranty, something you’ll definitely need to consider when choosing which well pump you want.

The estimated price for the Simple Pump is $1,500-2000. There typically isn’t any professional installation fee, because it’s fairly easy to install yourself.

Note, that you’ll need to change this at least once per decade.

On the other hand, Bison Pumps cost $1800-2100 typically. This does not include installation fees that are probably necessary for most. This isn’t much of a price jump, given that Bison Pumps last a lifetime.

So, in terms of price, Simple Pumps win by a hair but will need to be replaced much more frequently.

Now, when talking about warranties, the Simple Pump offers a limited lifetime warranty against defective materials. This does not include wear from normal use.

On the contrary, Bison Pumps offer a lifetime warranty, against defective materials and wear from normal use.

So, in terms of their warranties, Bison Pumps blow Simple Pumps out of the park.

What to Look for in a Well Pump?

There are many different factors that you should take into account when you are looking for a new well pump. Here are some of the most important factors to keep in mind: 

  1. The type of well pump that you need will depend on the depth of your well. If you have a shallow well, you will need a different type of pump than if you have a deep well.
  2. The flow rate of the pump is also an important factor to consider. You will want to make sure that the pump can provide enough water for your needs. 
  3. The price of the pump is also an important consideration. You will want to make sure that you are getting a good deal on the pump.
  4. The warranty is also an important consideration. You will want to make sure that the pump is covered in case it breaks down.
  5. The quality of the pump is essential. Especially in rough terrains, having a quality pump is essential.

By the way, using a well shouldn’t be your only way of getting water. Here are five ways to collect rainwater.

Final Words

So, that is our comparison of the Bison Pump Vs Simple Pump. Overall, Bison Pumps are your go-to because they’re just slightly more expensive while providing a lot more bang for your buck. 

But, there are a few cases where the Simple Pump may be a better option. If you need to extract water up from 301-325 feet, for example, the Simple Pump may be your best bet.

What pump will you get? Let us know in the comments down below.

Leave a Comment